“Rotating Snakes” Illusion

from Michael’s   Visual Phenomena & Optical Illusions

icon

rotsnake

Background

The image above is modified just a little from the original “Rotating Snakes” by Akiyoshi Kitaoka. It demonstrates strong (and beautiful) rotation of the “wheels”, occurring in relation to eye movements. On steady fixation the effect vanishes.

Comment

As Kitaoka & Ashida (2003) describe, asymmetric luminance steps are required. Gregory & Heard (1983) were the first to describe that asymmetric luminance steps cause illusory movement.

Recently we found to our surpricse that with certain luminance relations the wheels can turn in the opposite direction (Atala-Gérard & Bach, 2017).

We just calculated a simple model (preprint) showing that this illusion is a trivial consequence when you couple motion detectors into arrays with a little non-linearity.

A “Stress Test”? – No!

Repeatedly, I was sent such pictures with the assertion that they could be used as a stress test, and some senders were deeply worried. Also I found a web page entitled “test online the level of stress” (I will not link to it) which contains these statements “For a normal person, they should all move at a slow pace, barely rotating. The slower the pictures rotate, the better your ability of handling stress: Allegedly, criminals see stress test images moving and spinning around madly, while seniors and children see them still. …”

This is utter BS! Do not become alarmed. For one, the effect depends on eye movements, and these are known to differ markedly between subjects without relating in a clear-cut way to psychological traits. Further, a few people do not see it at all (could be around 5%, among them a very renowned vision scientist), in spite of appropriate eye movements. There are no actual data showing relations to stress (or age), so don’t distress yourself when you see it rotating strongly or not at all.

After my comments above, this fact check by USA Today arrived at same conclusion. Particularly funny: The false claim attributed »the illusion to “Japanese Psychotherapist Yamamoto Hashima” and claimed interpretation of the image could reveal dangerous exhaustion.”« And the fact check revealed »“Japanese psychotherapist Yamamoto Hashima has nothing to do with this picture,” … “Moreover, Yamamoto Hashima does not really exist.”«

Sources

Bach M, Atala-Gérard L 2020 The Rotating Snake Illusion is a straightforward consequence of non-linearity in arrays of standard motion detectors. BioRXiv PDF

Gregory RL, Heard PF (1983) Visual dissociations of movement, position, and stereo depth: Some phenomenal phenomena. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 35A:217–237 [PDF]

Kitaoka A, Ashida H (2003) Phenomenal characteristics of the peripheral drift illusion. VISION 15:261–262 PDF

Backus & Oruc 2004 VSS presentation abstract + background material

Conway BR, Kitaoka A, Yazdanbakhsh A, Pack CC, & Livingstone MS (2005) Neural basis for a powerful static motion illusion. J Neurosci 25:5651–5656

Backus & Oruc (2005) Illusory motion from change over time in the response to contrast and luminance. Journal of Vision 5:1055–1069

Atala-Gérard L, Bach M (2017) Rotating Snakes Illusion – Quantitative analysis reveals a region in luminance space with opposite illusory rotation. iPerception 8(1):2041669517691779